Table of Contents
Verdict: Medicare Advantage is worth it in 2027 if you expect a light year of care, are happy to use a local network and want the lowest fixed premium. It is not worth it if you expect heavy medical bills, split your time between states, or want to keep the option of a Medigap policy later, because that door can close. On 2027 figures from CMS and KFF read on 20 November 2026, a $0-premium plan costs about $2,447 less than Original Medicare with Medigap Plan G and a drug plan in a light year with $600 of copays, and up to $6,803 more in a year when you hit the plan's in-network cap.
Medicare Open Enrollment for 2027 coverage runs from 15 October to 7 December 2026, so the window to switch for 1 January is now short (CMS). The figures below are US federal Medicare amounts in US dollars.
Last updated: 20 November 2026. Premiums, caps and enrollment rules re-checked against CMS, Medicare.gov and KFF pages on this date.
In Brief
- The highest in-network out-of-pocket limit a Medicare Advantage plan may set rises to $9,850 in 2027, from $9,250 in 2026 (CMS CY 2027 MOOP calculations).
- CMS projects the average Medicare Advantage premium falls to $12.00 a month in 2027, from $14.37 (CMS). You still pay the $209.40 Part B premium on either route (Federal Register).
- Original Medicare has no yearly out-of-pocket limit unless you add supplemental coverage such as Medigap (Medicare.gov). KFF put the average Plan G premium among current policyholders at $194 a month in 2025 (KFF).
- In our worked example the break-even point is about $3,047 of in-network Medicare Advantage cost sharing in a year. Below that, the $0 plan is cheaper. Above it, Medigap Plan G is cheaper.
- Going back is the hard part. Outside your one-time Medigap window and a few protected situations, Medigap insurers can generally use medical underwriting, and KFF estimated 74% of Medicare Advantage enrollees in 2023 had a condition that could trigger a denial (KFF).
What each route costs in 2027
Both routes start with the same Part B bill, so the choice comes down to the premiums you add and what you pay when you use care. The table sets out the 2027 cost items, and each row links to its source.
| Cost item (2027) | Medicare Advantage | Original Medicare + Medigap Plan G + Part D | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part B premium | $209.40 a month (standard), paid on both routes | $209.40 a month (standard) | Federal Register, 19 Nov 2026 |
| Extra premium | Average $12.00 a month projected; 75% of individual-plan enrollees with drug cover paid no extra premium in 2026 | Medigap Plan G averaged $194 a month in 2025; stand-alone Part D projected at $36 a month | CMS; KFF; KFF |
| Part B deductible | Set by the plan | $292 a year (Plan G does not cover it) | Medicare.gov; KFF |
| Yearly cap on medical costs | In-network limit up to $9,850; combined in- and out-of-network up to $14,800 | No cap in Original Medicare; Plan G pays the rest of covered cost sharing after the Part B deductible | CMS; Medicare.gov |
| Drug cost cap | $2,400 out-of-pocket cap on covered Part D drugs | $2,400 out-of-pocket cap on covered Part D drugs | Medicare.gov |
Two things stand out. The fixed cost of the Medigap route is much higher, and it is paid whether or not you see a doctor. The Medicare Advantage route trades that for a cap that is far above what a Plan G holder would normally pay in a year, so its value depends on how much care you use.
What changed for 2027
Most 2027 changes are small, but they all move the break-even point. This table compares the 2026 and 2027 figures from CMS and Medicare.gov.
| Item | 2026 | 2027 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Highest in-network MA out-of-pocket limit | $9,250 | $9,850 | CMS |
| Average MA premium (projected) | $14.37 a month | $12.00 a month | CMS |
| Average stand-alone Part D premium (projected) | $35.09 a month | $36 a month | CMS |
| Part D out-of-pocket cap | $2,100 | $2,400 | Medicare.gov |
| Part B premium / deductible | $202.90 / $283 | $209.40 / $292 | Federal Register |
CMS's calculation file shows the 2027 cap rose 6.49%, after it fell 1.07% for 2026 (CMS). CMS also expects about 34 million people, around 47.4% of everyone enrolled in Medicare, to be in Medicare Advantage in 2027, based on plan projections it says have historically understated enrollment (CMS). KFF counted 55% of eligible beneficiaries, those with both Parts A and B, in Medicare Advantage in 2026 (KFF).
For the Part B side in more detail, including income-related surcharges, see our Medicare Part B premium 2027 guide.
The break-even test: where a $0 plan stops saving money
A $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan is cheaper than Medigap Plan G until your own cost sharing in the plan passes the Medigap route's fixed yearly cost. In this example that point is about $3,047. This is an illustration built on the assumptions below, not a quote for any plan.
Assumptions (all amounts per year, US dollars, 2027 federal figures unless stated):
- One person aged 65 or over with premium-free Part A who pays the standard Part B premium. That premium ($209.40 × 12 = $2,512.80) is the same on both routes, so it is left out of the comparison (Federal Register).
- Medicare Advantage route: a plan with prescription drug coverage and a $0 premium. KFF found 75% of people in individual plans with drug coverage paid no premium beyond Part B in 2026 (KFF).
- Medigap route: Plan G at KFF's 2025 national average of $194 a month, which KFF puts at $2,323 for 12 months (KFF). 2027 quotes will differ by state, age and insurer. Add a stand-alone drug plan at CMS's projected $36 a month, or $432 (CMS), and the $292 Part B deductible, which Plan G does not cover (Medicare.gov).
- Same doctors, all in network, same Medicare-covered services and the same drugs on both routes. Drug spending is capped at $2,400 on either route, so it is left out apart from the drug-plan premium.
- Fixed yearly cost of the Medigap route: $2,323 + $432 + $292 = $3,047, assuming you use enough Part B care to meet the deductible.
| Year you have | Medicare Advantage ($0 plan) | Original Medicare + Plan G + Part D | Which costs less |
|---|---|---|---|
| Light year: $600 of in-network copays | $600 | $3,047 | Medicare Advantage, by $2,447 |
| Break-even year: $3,047 of copays | $3,047 | $3,047 | Even |
| You hit a cap at KFF's 2026 average ($5,421) | $5,421 | $3,047 | Medigap, by $2,374 |
| You hit the 2027 legal maximum ($9,850) | $9,850 | $3,047 | Medigap, by $6,803 |
The $5,421 row uses KFF's 2026 average in-network out-of-pocket limit for Medicare Advantage enrollees, because a 2027 average was not published in the sources we read (KFF). Out-of-network care in a PPO can count toward a higher combined limit of up to $14,800 (CMS).
The break-even point moves with your Medigap price. Using KFF's 2025 state averages for Plan G shows the range:
| Plan G premium (KFF 2025 average) | Plan G per year | Medigap route fixed cost | Break-even MA copays |
|---|---|---|---|
| $164 a month (New Mexico, lowest non-waiver state in KFF data) | $1,968 | $2,692 | About $2,692 |
| $194 a month (national average) | $2,323 (KFF's annual figure) | $3,047 | About $3,047 |
| $257 a month (New York, highest state shown) | $3,084 | $3,808 | About $3,808 |
So in this model the plan pays off for people whose yearly copays stay under roughly $2,700 to $3,800, depending on their state. In Original Medicare a hospital admission carries a $1,776 Part A deductible per benefit period in 2027, which Plan G covers; in a Medicare Advantage plan, what you pay for a stay is set by the plan, up to its yearly limit (Medicare.gov; KFF; Medicare.gov).
What you get with Medicare Advantage
The main gains are a lower fixed cost, a hard cap and extras in one card. Plans must cover all medically necessary services that Original Medicare covers, and most include drug coverage, so you do not need a separate Part D plan (Medicare.gov). Some plans may also help pay all or part of your Part B premium (Medicare.gov).
- A yearly limit. Once you reach your plan's limit you pay nothing more for covered Medicare services that year (Medicare.gov). Original Medicare on its own has no limit.
- Extras. In 2026, more than 99% of individual-plan enrollees had eye exams and/or glasses, 98% dental, 95% hearing and 91% a fitness benefit (KFF). How generous those benefits are varies by plan.
- Low premiums. CMS says more than 99% of beneficiaries can choose at least one plan in 2027 and 97% have ten or more (CMS).
What it costs you beyond the premium
The costs that are not in dollars are networks, approvals and plans that change every year. These are the trade-offs Medicare.gov and KFF describe:
- Networks. You may need to use in-network doctors for non-emergency care and get referrals for specialists (Medicare.gov).
- Prior authorization. 99% of enrollees were in plans that required prior authorization for some services in 2026. Medicare Advantage insurers received nearly 53 million requests in 2024 and denied 4.1 million, nearly 8% (KFF). Original Medicare rarely uses prior authorization, according to the same KFF analysis.
- Travel. Plans generally do not cover care outside the US, though some offer emergency cover abroad as an extra. With Original Medicare you can buy a Medigap policy that covers emergency care outside the US (Medicare.gov).
- Yearly change. Plan costs and benefits can change from year to year, so CMS encourages people to review their coverage and compare options each Open Enrollment (CMS).
The switch-back problem
You can leave Medicare Advantage at set times each year. Getting Medigap back is harder. Your federal Medigap Open Enrollment Period lasts six months from the first month you have Part B and are 65 or older. During that window insurers cannot refuse you or charge more for pre-existing conditions. It does not repeat (Medicare.gov).
If you joined Medicare Advantage when first eligible at 65, or dropped a Medigap policy to join a plan for the first time, you have one 12-month trial period to return to Original Medicare with rights to buy certain Medigap policies (Medicare.gov). After that, KFF says Medigap insurers can generally use medical underwriting. Its analysis found 74% of full-year Medicare Advantage enrollees in 2023, or about 20.9 million people, had a pre-existing condition that could lead to a Medigap denial (KFF). Four states, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine and New York, require insurers to offer Medigap to everyone aged 65 and older on a continuous or annual basis regardless of medical history (KFF).
If you are already in a plan, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from 1 January to 31 March lets you switch plans or return to Original Medicare and add a drug plan (Medicare.gov). Whether you can also buy Medigap then depends on your state and your rights.
Worth it for you, or not?
Likely worth it if you
- expect few doctor visits and no planned surgery next year, so your copays stay below the break-even range above;
- would struggle to pay a Plan G premium every month and prefer a capped worst case;
- are happy with the plan's local network and your doctors are in it;
- value dental, vision or hearing extras and have checked what the plan actually pays for them.
Likely not worth it if you
- have a condition that already brings high yearly bills, where the cap could become your real cost;
- live in two states or travel a lot, or want to see any doctor who takes Medicare;
- are inside your six-month Medigap window and can afford Plan G, since that guaranteed chance does not come back;
- want to avoid prior authorization for hospital, nursing facility and home health care.
Planning retirement income around these costs? Our Social Security cuts explainer covers whether benefits could be cut in 2032, and our senior tax deduction guide explains when the $6,000 deduction ends.
Final Thoughts
For 2027 the arithmetic is simple even if the decision is not. Medicare Advantage wins on fixed cost and loses on worst-case cost, and the plan's worst case rose as the legal cap went up to $9,850. Compare actual 2027 plans in the Medicare Plan Finder before 7 December 2026. Get a real Plan G quote from your state, because KFF's averages are only a starting point. If you are new to Medicare, decide before your Medigap window closes.
Sources (all read on 20 November 2026): CMS, Medicare Advantage and Part D programs expected to remain stable in 2027 (28 Sep 2026); CMS, Medicare Advantage Rates & Statistics; CMS, CY 2027 MOOP and cost sharing limit calculations (ZIP); Federal Register, Medicare Part B premium and deductible for 2027 (19 Nov 2026); Medicare.gov, What does Medicare cost?; Medicare.gov, Drug coverage costs; Medicare.gov, Compare Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage; Medicare.gov, Joining a plan; Medicare.gov, How Medigap works; Medicare.gov, Medigap Open Enrollment and guaranteed issue rights; KFF, Key facts about Medigap enrollment and premiums (13 Oct 2026); KFF, Medicare Advantage in 2026: premiums, out-of-pocket limits, supplemental benefits and prior authorization (5 Jun 2026); KFF, Medicare Advantage in 2026: enrollment update (5 Jun 2026, updated 1 Jul 2026); KFF, Nearly three-quarters of Medicare Advantage enrollees could be denied a Medigap policy (13 Oct 2026).
This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and doesn't constitute financial, investment, legal, tax or medical advice. Figures were read on 20 November 2026 from CMS, Medicare.gov, the Federal Register and KFF and apply to US Medicare. Plan premiums, networks, caps and Medigap prices vary by plan, state and person. The worked example uses stated assumptions, not plan quotes. Check the Medicare Plan Finder or call 1-800-MEDICARE before you choose coverage. No insurer or provider is endorsed or paid for placement.