Table of Contents
The S&P 500 is the better core holding for most long-term investors, and the Nasdaq-100 is the better pick only if you want a deliberate tilt to large tech-led growth companies and can sit through much deeper falls. Over the ten years to 31 October 2026 the Nasdaq-100 returned 20.51% a year against 15.44% for the S&P 500 (Invesco, State Street). Over the past year, though, the S&P 500 did better, and the current sell-off has hit the Nasdaq-100 hardest.
At the close on 20 November 2026 the Nasdaq-100 stood at 25,028.98, 20.2% below its 6 October intraday high of 31,361.37. The S&P 500 closed at 6,910.39, 11.9% below its own 6 October high of 7,844.52 (CNBC Nasdaq-100 quote, CNBC S&P 500 quote; percentages are our calculation). Costs differ too: the big S&P 500 ETFs charge as little as 0.03% a year, against 0.15% to 0.18% for Invesco's Nasdaq-100 funds.
Last updated: 22 November 2026. Index data, fund fees and holdings re-checked on Nasdaq, Invesco, State Street, iShares, Vanguard and CNBC pages on this date. All figures are in US dollars and describe US-listed funds and US indexes.
Highlights
- Growth versus breadth: the Nasdaq-100 holds about 100 non-financial Nasdaq-listed companies. The S&P 500 holds about 500 large US companies across all 11 sectors, including banks and insurers.
- Concentration: the ten largest stocks make up 46.86% of the Nasdaq-100 and 36.95% of the S&P 500, on the latest index data each provider publishes.
- Returns depend on the window: the Nasdaq-100 led by about 5 points a year over ten years, by only 1.2 points over five years (which include 2022), and it trailed the S&P 500 over one year.
- Fees: on $10,000, a year costs $3 in VOO or IVV, $9.45 in SPY, $15 in QQQM and $18 in QQQ.
First, which "Nasdaq"?
Most "Nasdaq vs S&P 500" questions are really about the Nasdaq-100, because that is the index the big Nasdaq funds track. The name covers two different indexes:
- Nasdaq Composite (COMP): nearly every common stock listed on the Nasdaq Stock Market, 3,396 securities on 30 September 2026, including financial companies (Nasdaq Composite factsheet). News reports usually mean this one when they say "the Nasdaq fell".
- Nasdaq-100 (NDX): 100 of the largest non-financial companies listed on Nasdaq, 101 securities on 30 September 2026 because some companies have two share classes (Nasdaq-100 factsheet). Invesco's QQQ and QQQM track it.
The S&P 500 measures the large-cap segment of the US stock market. It is weighted by float-adjusted market capitalisation and holds companies in all eleven GICS sectors, 503 securities on 19 November 2026 (State Street SPY page). It is not tied to one exchange, so Nasdaq-listed Apple, Microsoft and Nvidia are its three largest holdings, alongside NYSE-listed names such as Berkshire Hathaway.
The Nasdaq-100 rules are stricter about sector and venue. Under the Nasdaq-100 methodology, a company has to be listed on Nasdaq and must not be classified as Financial under the Industry Classification Benchmark. It also needs average daily trading of at least $5 million. The index is reconstituted every December. When companies weighing more than 4.5% each add up to 48% or more of the index, that group is cut back to 40% in total, a cap that matters with so few names at the top. Invesco notes that new weighting and maintenance rules took effect on 1 May 2026 (Invesco QQQM page).
The two indexes side by side
The first table compares what each index holds and what it costs to own through the largest funds. Each cell links to the provider page it came from. Dates differ because each provider publishes on its own schedule.
| Criterion | Nasdaq-100 | S&P 500 | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Our pick: best use | A growth tilt next to a core fund | Core long-term holding for most investors | S&P 500 |
| Holdings | 101 securities (30 Sep 2026) | 503 securities (19 Nov 2026) | S&P 500, broader |
| Tech weight | Technology 68.01% (ICB industry) | Information Technology 35.56% (GICS sector) | S&P 500, less tilted |
| Financials | Excluded by rule (0.00%) | 12.63% | S&P 500, more sectors |
| Top 10 weight | 46.86% (factsheet, 30 Sep) | 36.95% (index top holdings, 19 Nov) | S&P 500, less top-heavy |
| Cheapest large ETF | QQQM 0.15%; QQQ 0.18% | VOO 0.03%; IVV 0.03%; SPY 0.0945% | S&P 500 |
| Fund income (30-day SEC yield) | QQQM 0.47% (19 Nov) | SPY 1.03% (19 Nov) | S&P 500 |
Two patterns stand out. The Nasdaq-100 is roughly twice as exposed to technology as the S&P 500, although the two use different classification systems (ICB for Nasdaq, GICS for S&P), so treat the sector figures as a guide rather than an exact match. And the Nasdaq-100's top ten carry almost half the index, so a bad week for a handful of chipmakers and platforms moves it much more.
Returns: the Nasdaq-100's lead depends on the window
The Nasdaq-100 has beaten the S&P 500 over ten years, but not over every period. The table uses total returns (dividends reinvested) to 31 October 2026, annualised for three years and longer. These are index returns and don't include fund fees.
| Period to 31 Oct 2026 | Nasdaq-100 | S&P 500 | Gap (points) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year to date | 12.98% | 11.77% | +1.21 Nasdaq-100 |
| 1 year | 10.47% | 12.11% | +1.64 S&P 500 |
| 3 years, a year | 26.28% | 23.40% | +2.88 Nasdaq-100 |
| 5 years, a year | 13.23% | 12.06% | +1.17 Nasdaq-100 |
| 10 years, a year | 20.51% | 15.44% | +5.07 Nasdaq-100 |
Sources: Nasdaq-100 total returns from Invesco QQQ; S&P 500 index returns from State Street SPY. Gaps are our subtraction.
In dollars, $10,000 growing at those ten-year rates would have reached about $64,600 in the Nasdaq-100 and about $42,000 in the S&P 500, before fees and taxes. The five-year figures tell the other side of the story. That window includes 2022, when the Nasdaq-100 fell 32.97% on a price basis (Nasdaq factsheet), and that one year erased most of its lead. The index's ten-year annualised volatility was 22.78% on the same factsheet, a reminder that the higher return came with bigger swings.
Risk: what this sell-off shows
The current sell-off has hit the Nasdaq-100 about twice as hard as the S&P 500. By the 20 November close the Nasdaq-100 was 20.2% below its 6 October intraday high, while the S&P 500 was 11.9% below its high from the same day (CNBC, CNBC). On 20 November alone the Nasdaq-100 fell 5.61%, leaving it up just 0.62% over one year (Nasdaq).
Concentration explains most of the gap. When the stocks driving the AI trade fall together, the index with 46.86% in its top ten takes the bigger hit. Our report on why the stock market is falling covers the day-by-day moves. For how past Nasdaq drawdowns played out, see the Nasdaq correction tracker.
On the other hand, the S&P 500 is not a defensive fund. Its own top ten still make up more than a third of the index, and the same mega-cap names lead both lists. Diversifying away from big tech means adding other assets, not just swapping one index for the other.
Costs: what $10,000 pays in fund fees
Fees are the one difference you know in advance. The worked example below uses each fund's published expense ratio and two simple assumptions: a $10,000 investment, and the same 8% yearly return before fees for every fund, so that only the fee changes the result. The 8% is an illustration, not a forecast.
| Fund (index) | Expense ratio | Fee in year one | After 10 years at 8% less fees | Cost vs no fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VOO (Vanguard, S&P 500) | 0.03% | $3.00 | $21,529 | $60 |
| IVV (iShares, S&P 500) | 0.03% | $3.00 | $21,529 | $60 |
| SPY (SPDR, S&P 500) | 0.0945% | $9.45 | $21,401 | $188 |
| QQQM (Invesco, Nasdaq-100) | 0.15% | $15.00 | $21,291 | $298 |
| QQQ (Invesco, Nasdaq-100) | 0.18% | $18.00 | $21,232 | $357 |
Calculation: $10,000 × (1.08 − expense ratio)10, compared with $21,589 for a fund with no fee. Brokerage commissions, bid-ask spreads and taxes are left out. Vanguard's VOO ratio is dated 28 April 2026; the others were shown on 22 November 2026.
The fee gap between the cheapest S&P 500 fund and QQQ is about $300 over ten years on $10,000, small next to the 5-point return gaps above. If you have already chosen the Nasdaq-100, QQQM tracks the same index as QQQ for 0.03 points less. QQQ's main draw is its trading volume, which matters mostly to active traders and options users.
Who each index suits
Nasdaq-100: for a growth tilt you can hold through a 30% fall
The Nasdaq-100 suits investors with a long horizon who already hold a broad core fund and want extra exposure to the largest tech, consumer and biotech companies on Nasdaq.
- Pros: the stronger ten-year record (20.51% a year); concentrated exposure to the big platform and chip companies; QQQ is the second most-traded US ETF by average daily volume, according to Invesco.
- Cons: no banks, insurers or companies listed only on the NYSE; almost half the index in ten stocks; it fell 32.97% in 2022 and has fallen hardest this autumn; higher fees and lower income than S&P 500 funds.
- Not ideal for: money you might need within a few years, or a portfolio's only equity fund.
S&P 500: for a single core holding
The S&P 500 suits investors who want one low-cost fund covering most of the US stock market's value, including financials, health care and industrials.
- Pros: about 500 companies across all 11 sectors; fees as low as 0.03%; higher income (SPY's 30-day SEC yield was 1.03%); a smaller fall in the current sell-off.
- Cons: still dominated by the same mega-cap tech names; it trailed the Nasdaq-100 by about 5 points a year over the past decade; it holds only US large caps.
- Not ideal for: investors who specifically want to overweight growth companies, or anyone looking for protection in a tech sell-off.
Choosing where to buy the funds? Our Robinhood vs Webull comparison covers two popular US brokers. Investors in India comparing their own two benchmarks can read Nifty 50 vs Sensex.
Where This Leaves Us: a decision guide
- One fund for the long term: choose an S&P 500 fund (VOO or IVV at 0.03%).
- You already own the S&P 500 and want more growth: add a smaller Nasdaq-100 position through QQQM, knowing it largely doubles up on the same top holdings.
- You trade actively or use options: QQQ and SPY are built for it. Invesco ranks QQQ the second most-traded US ETF, and State Street shows a 0.00% 30-day median bid-ask spread for SPY (Invesco, State Street). The extra fee matters less over a short hold.
- You need the money within about three years: neither index fits well. Both have fallen more than 10% since 6 October.
- You want income: the S&P 500 pays roughly twice the yield of the Nasdaq-100 funds.
Quick Answers
Is the Nasdaq in a bear market?
Can I hold both a Nasdaq-100 and an S&P 500 fund?
Which is better for a beginner, QQQ or VOO?
Sources: Nasdaq-100 factsheet and Nasdaq Composite factsheet (data as of 30 September 2026); Nasdaq-100 index methodology; Nasdaq-100 index overview (data as of 20 November 2026); Invesco QQQ and Invesco QQQM fund pages; State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY); iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV); Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO); CNBC quotes for the S&P 500 and Nasdaq-100. All read on 22 November 2026.
This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and doesn't constitute financial, investment, legal or tax advice. Index data, returns, holdings, yields and expense ratios for the Nasdaq-100, Nasdaq Composite and S&P 500, and for Invesco QQQ and QQQM, SPDR SPY, iShares IVV and Vanguard VOO, were read from official provider pages and CNBC on 22 November 2026, carry the as-of dates shown, and can change at any time. Past performance does not guarantee future results. The worked fee example uses an assumed return and is not a forecast. Index returns do not include fund fees, and you cannot invest directly in an index.